So based on this the treasure cave has returned improved with less traps. Surprise, surprise I reached my first trap on door 3...just like it was before the improvements.

@nynaevelan
First impression of the new treasure cave
main account: trap before reaching first safe door (5) food and gold so that was no way I will spend 4 gems
other account: trap before reaching first safe door (5) 2 orbs and I believe gold already forgot not worth gems
lower chance on hitting trap door????
keys as reward love the idea but not this way, 25% at 1 key = 1/5 vault space buying a spot in Vault prob is cheaper who would do that???
if the keys where a possibility behind the normal doors and I got 1 I would happily gamble the 4 gems to have a chance on another one

I got my trap at the second door, lol

Trap at 3rd door for me too

Let's see who can beat this:
I get an error message at the first door.

after getting "unknown error" for hours i finally managed ...what for you might ask ...or not , well, 2nd and 4th door traps...not same account, wouldn't pay 4 gems for 7.5 k GOLD lol hilarious sooo, i did not went further , it was enough to quench my curiosity

it's sooo baaaad !!!

3 traps reach the door 4

I wanted to start similar thread but you got me first. NOTHING has improved. Got traps in doors 4 and 8. The rewards are useless as always. The UI has improved slightly and now shows the possible rewards at "joker" rooms.

Still disappointing at the current form.

2nd trap definitely new not so much improved

3 attempts at caves so far not got past 5th door absolutely shocking that there saying this is improved I enjoyed caves before as said in previous post used to get some orbs and gems so far nothing out of this new and improved nonsense.

At first, clicking on the treasure cave did absolutely nothing...just highlighted the cave. So, I then updated my app in the Play Store. Now I can get to the cave but I get the unknown error others have reported whenever I click on a door.

@trogdor said in New Treasure Cave? Improved? I don't think so:

At first, clicking on the treasure cave did absolutely nothing...just highlighted the cave. So, I then updated my app in the Play Store. Now I can get to the cave but I get the unknown error others have reported whenever I click on a door.

Try clearing your cache to see if that resolves the issue. If not, I suggest you send in a ticket.

Room 3 trap twice ...

@marco-diaz i need proof of that to believe it tbh

please remove this feature, it's totally useless

First attempt : traps in 2nd and 4th floor
Second : trap in 2nd floor

Hilarous....
No more cave for me

@marianne-van-es you want the proof there is any improvements in cave

Edit: the picture so everybody can see it without clicking on the link

@marco-diaz thanks, that is terrible please send a ticket to support to claim your 10 gems back

The sooner they get rid of this stupid feature, the better!

Before: Normally reached Floor 5 and left then, means 2 free gems and some little stuff every day + 1 gem in daily missions

Now: Don‘t even reach floor 3, just a little bit of gold and food - just stupid !

Laughably bad in its new 'improved' state. Pitiful rewards even if lucky enough to reach door 5. Original version seemed spot on, not guaranteed success but there were occasional opportunities for a lucky streak to be rewarded in gerting to room 30. The next 'tweaked ' version was worse but you could get a few gems and cells for free most days....and now this. Steady downhill progress so far, for a feature that could work so much better for players and SP. We'll invest as players if the chances equal the rewards and effort.

ITS A TRAP. They are not kidding

i just don't get it , 3rd try for me and trap before room 5 ...so what's the incentive to go further here ??? seriously what are they thinking ? how can we spend our gems for nothing ..., makes no sense , i haven't heard as of yet of anyone that went ahead with this ...IT'S DUMB !!!!! i was so much happier with previous version, they could get some gems from me for meager rewards but for this i refuse to even keep clicking it !

@gazza i so wish i had the ROFL emoticon here

The old one was better.

Somehow managed to get to now traps up until room 9. I wasn't expecting much but I still am disappointed. Oh well, that one Fire elemental cell was decent to get

@david-ml The feature in its original form was good never spent a gem on it but if I was lucky could get few gems orbs cells for nothing and didn’t take up much time as usual with sp wasn’t making them enough so they figure bring out this crazy version.

it seems that SP doesn‘t get enough money out of this event. So they have to optimize it

Everytime when SP says they want to make something better I get panic

@nynaevelan This has to be much worst then before they removed it. You don’t get random gems behind the doors and traps are so rigged you can’t even get to the first treasure room without spending gems making this s total waste of time. They should rename it to no loot cave.

No random gems on any and all doors not worth it.
At least in the past, I'd have a chance to score 4 gems before hitting a trap. Now, pointless.

Door 2,trap. Why would anyone pay gems for 7.5k gold or food?

Yep, with the old cave I would usually play to door 10 or the 1st trap and then decide whether the loot is worth 4 gems. It wasn't a lot but I reckon I got a small lot of cells and other goodies 4-5 times each week. This new one is beyond useless!!!

why!! this was being the best attempt after the rework, until now i only got food and gold

I've used the Treasure Cave every time it's available. I've never made it past door 4 without a trap.

I am officially done with it, it is a waste of time and I am certainly not using any gems on it.

My advice dont let it return

@marianne-van-es Let it return in its original form was good no need to change got free orbs free gems but that didn’t suit sp.

It was better the previous one, at least we could get some goodies out of it, wasn't that much though, but it helped somehow. This new version is disappointing and frustrating, lower costs but more traps. If it's going to be like this, I'll pass

This event was complete garbage. Neither me nor my girlfriend could get past door 4 without without a trap, with many attempts getting traps at doors 2 and 3. The rewards were mostly low amounts of gold and food mixed in with maybe 1 elemental cell or orbs if you got to door 4. This was in no way an improvement over the previous treasure cave. I don't see anyone spending gems on this version of the cave. Bring back the previous version or get rid of it altogether.

@sansot same here.

More traps than before is not a good thing, even with the lowered costs (after a while they costs become huge).

And here I thought it would be impossible to screw up a re-work more than live duels but the cave somehow did it.

...ah SP - you've done it again

The treasure cave is an insult to any player. It was before and it still is.

I'm kind of glad that my kids have stopped playing ML, but when the cave first came out I had to explain the "all or nothing" gambling mechanic behind this feature to my kids and warned them to not waste their precious few gems on it. I find it disgusting that such mechanics are allowed in games played by children!!!

@nynaevelan I too got very low rewards & Coal Cave at 2/3/4 Doors! Unbelievably worse! I never spent any gems when I got a Coal Cave to continue! Sadly the expensive "Treasure Cave" was worse! It makes no sense to pay 4 gems to continue with low chance of even making those back.